There are a lot of smokers out there, and the hard part is that there isn’t one single “best smoker” for everyone.
A pellet smoker, charcoal smoker, kamado, electric smoker, drum smoker, and offset smoker all cook differently. Some are almost set-and-forget. Some need a lot more fire management. Some are better for grilling as well as smoking, while others are really only built for low and slow barbecue.
I’ve cooked on a lot of different smokers over the years, and this guide is my honest pick of the smokers I’d actually recommend for backyard BBQ. Not just the most expensive models. Not just the ones every other list repeats. And not smokers I wouldn’t personally be happy using.
Below, I’ve picked the best smoker in each main category so you can quickly work out which style suits the way you actually want to cook.
Burning Brisket is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read our affiliate policy to learn more.
Quick Picks: Best Smokers on the Market
These are my top smoker picks based on real-world backyard use, not just feature lists.
🥇 Best Overall Smoker
IF YOU WANT: A dependable pellet smoker for regular backyard BBQ without paying a premium.
🔥 Best Charcoal
IF YOU WANT: Real charcoal flavor with digital temperature control instead of adjusting vents all day.
🧱 Best Kamado Smoker
IF YOU WANT: A charcoal smoker and grill that holds heat well without paying extra for the Classic III.
⚡ Best Electric Smoker
IF YOU WANT: A simple plug-in smoker for fish, ribs, chicken, and pork with very little fire management.
🛢️ Best Drum Smoker
IF YOU WANT: A charcoal drum smoker that can handle low and slow BBQ plus hot grilling.
🪵 Best Offset Smoker
IF YOU WANT: A real offset smoker for learning fire management without spending thousands.
Table of Contents
Best Smokers on the Market Compared
Here’s a quick side-by-side comparison of our top smokers on the market before diving into the full reviews.
| Smoker | Type | Cooking Area | Best For | Effort Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Z Grills 700D4E | Pellet smoker | Approx. 697 sq in | Easy backyard smoking | Low |
| Masterbuilt Gravity Series | Digital charcoal smoker | Varies by model | Charcoal flavor with less fire management | Low-medium |
| Kamado Joe Classic II | Ceramic kamado | Approx. 406 sq in standard setup | Smoking, grilling, roasting, and fuel efficiency | Medium |
| East Oak 30” Electric Smoker | Electric smoker | Approx. 725 sq in | Simple plug-in smoking | Low |
| Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco | Charcoal drum smoker | 18” grate + hooks | Drum smoking and charcoal grilling | Medium |
| Oklahoma Joe’s Highland | Offset smoker | Approx. 619 sq in main chamber | Learning traditional offset smoking | High |
What to Expect From These Smokers
Every smoker here can make good BBQ, but they do not all suit the same person.
- If you want the easiest all-rounder, choose the Z Grills 700D4E. It is the most straightforward pick for regular ribs, pork, chicken, brisket, and weeknight cooking.
- If you want charcoal flavor without full fire management, choose the Masterbuilt Gravity Series. It gives you more charcoal character than a pellet smoker but still feels fairly modern to use.
- If you want one premium-feeling smoker that can also grill properly, choose the Kamado Joe Classic II. It is more hands-on than a pellet smoker, but it is also more versatile.
- If you want the simplest smoker possible, choose the East Oak electric. It is not the best choice for grilling or heavy smoke flavor, but it is very easy to live with.
- If you want a charcoal smoker that feels fun and practical, choose the Bronco. It is more hands-on than pellet or electric, but it has a really useful smoking and grilling setup.
- If you want to learn fire management, choose the Highland. It is not set-and-forget, and that is the whole point.
For a deeper breakdown of smoker types, read our guide to choosing the best type of smoker.
The Best Smokers Reviewed
Below are the smokers I’d look at first, based on how they cook in real use, how much effort they need, and whether they make sense for normal backyard barbecue.
I’ve kept the list tight because “best smoker” articles can get messy fast. Instead of adding every decent option, I’ve picked one strong recommendation for each main smoker type so you can choose based on how you actually want to cook.
BEST OVERALL
Z Grills 700D4E
The Z Grills 700D4E is my pick for the best overall smoker because it does the basics really well without pushing you into a premium price bracket. It is the smoker I’d recommend to most backyard cooks who want real BBQ results without managing charcoal, vents, or a wood fire.
Why this works
- It gives you enough cooking space for regular family BBQ and entertaining.
- The pellet system makes it easy to hold low and slow temperatures.
- The cabinet design is practical for storage and makes the smoker feel more substantial.
- It is a better fit for most people than chasing the most expensive pellet grill.
- It avoids the rear-vent/no-chimney design issues I’ve had with some other pellet smokers in windy conditions.
Cooking experience
The 700D4E is the sort of smoker that makes regular backyard BBQ easy. You fill the hopper, set the temperature, give it time to settle, and let it run. For ribs, pork shoulder, chicken, sausages, and everyday smoking, that simple pellet setup is exactly what most people need.
What I like about it is that it does not feel like you are fighting the smoker. It is not pretending to be a luxury grill, and it does not have every feature possible, but it gives you steady enough heat and a proper wood-fired flavor without much work. That makes it a smoker you actually use, not just one that sounds impressive on paper.
I also prefer this style of Z Grills design over some of the newer feature-heavy models for exposed sites. I live somewhere windy, and I’m not a huge fan of rear-vent designs with no chimney because wind can whip through and affect the cook. The 700D4E is a simpler, more sensible pick for the way I actually cook.
What to expect
- Easier to use than charcoal, kamado, drum, or offset smokers
- Good everyday smoker for ribs, pork, chicken, brisket, and sausages
- Not as smoky as charcoal or offset cooking
- No direct-flame grilling setup
- Still needs power and pellets to run
- Strongest choice here if you want regular BBQ without much effort
Pros
- Easy to use
- Good size for families and entertaining
- Practical cabinet design
- Reliable pellet smoker for regular BBQ
- Better value than many premium pellet grills
- Good choice if you want smoking without fire management
Cons
- Not as smoky as charcoal or offset cooking
- Fewer premium features than high-end pellet grills
- No direct flame grilling setup
- Still needs power to run
Who it's best for
Anyone who wants an easy full-size pellet smoker for regular backyard BBQ.
Who should skip it
If you want strong charcoal flavor, open-fire cooking, or proper grilling.
BEST CHARCOAL
Masterbuilt Gravity Series
The Masterbuilt Gravity Series is my pick for the best charcoal smoker because it gives you charcoal flavor without making you manage a traditional charcoal fire all day. It is not the best-built charcoal smoker on the market, but the cooking system works and the food it makes can be seriously good.
Read our full review of the Masterbuilt Gravity →
Why this works
- Runs on charcoal but uses a digital controller and fan
- Gives you more charcoal flavor than a pellet smoker
- Can smoke low and slow or grill at higher heat
- Comes in different sizes
- Good middle ground between convenience and charcoal cooking
Cooking experience
The Masterbuilt Gravity Series feels a bit like a charcoal version of a pellet smoker. You fill the hopper with charcoal, light it, set your target temperature, and the fan controls the airflow to keep the smoker running. Once it is going, it is much easier than managing vents on a traditional charcoal smoker.
In our testing, it did what it was meant to do. The temperature stayed impressively steady, and the food had that charcoal flavor you do not get from pellets or electric smokers. It is especially useful if you want the taste of charcoal but know you are not going to sit beside a smoker all day making tiny vent adjustments.
The main quirk is lighting it. It is not as instantly simple as pressing a button on a pellet smoker. You need to get the charcoal started properly before the system can do its thing. I’d also be careful with storage and weather because the build quality is not amazing, and these are known for needing a bit of care to avoid rust and wear.
What to expect
- Real charcoal flavor with less vent adjustment
- Easier than a normal charcoal smoker once lit
- More cleanup than pellet or electric
- Build quality is average, so storage matters
- Can grill as well as smoke
- Best choice here if you want charcoal flavor without full fire management
Pros
- Real charcoal flavor
- Much easier than managing a normal charcoal fire
- Digital temperature control
- Can smoke and grill
- Different sizes available
- Good option for people moving beyond pellet smoking
Cons
- Lighting can be annoying
- Build quality is average
- Needs proper storage and care
- More cleanup than pellet or electric
- Shorter warranty than I’d like
Who it's best for
If you want charcoal flavor with digital temperature control.
Who should skip it
If you want the easiest, cleanest, lowest-maintenance smoker.
Also available at: Walmart
BEST KAMADO
Kamado Joe Classic II
The Kamado Joe Classic II is my pick for the best kamado smoker because it gives you the main Kamado Joe benefits without making you pay extra for upgrades I do not think everyone needs. It smokes, grills, roasts, and holds heat incredibly well, which makes it one of the most versatile smokers on this list.
Read our full review of the Kamado Joe Classic II →
Why this works
- Excellent for both smoking and grilling
- Ceramic body holds heat extremely well
- Air Lift hinge makes the heavy lid easier to use
- Divide & Conquer system gives flexible cooking zones
- Gives most people the main Kamado Joe benefits without stepping up to the Classic III
Cooking experience
A kamado is very different from a pellet or electric smoker. It takes a bit more learning because you are controlling airflow and charcoal, but once you understand how it reacts, the Kamado Joe Classic II is incredibly steady. The ceramic body holds heat so well that small vent changes can go a long way.
For low and slow cooking, it is efficient and consistent. You do not burn through fuel the way you might expect, and once the temperature is settled, it can sit there for a long time. For grilling, it is in a different league to most pellet and electric smokers because it can get properly hot and cook over charcoal.
I’d choose the Classic II over the Classic III for most people because it has the main features that matter. The Classic III adds extras like the SlōRoller and a taller cart setup, but after comparing them, I do not think everyone needs to pay for those upgrades. The Classic II already gives you the important kamado experience.
What to expect
- More hands-on than pellet or electric
- Very steady once you learn the vents
- Excellent at both low smoking and hot grilling
- Heavy and not something you move around casually
- Cooking space is more limited than a large pellet smoker or offset
- Best choice here if you want one serious charcoal smoker and grill
Pros
- Excellent for smoking and grilling
- Very efficient with charcoal
- Holds temperature extremely well
- More premium than many backyard smokers
- Air Lift hinge makes the lid easier to handle
- Good long-term smoker if you want one cooker to do a lot
Cons
- Heavy
- More expensive than basic charcoal smokers
- Takes time to learn vent control
- Cooking space is not huge
- Not as hands-off as pellet or electric
Who it's best for
If you want one charcoal cooker that can smoke, grill, roast, and hold heat properly.
Who should skip it
If you want push-button smoking or a large cooking area for big groups.
For more detail on whether the newer model is worth paying for, read our Kamado Joe Classic II vs III comparison.
Also available at: Walmart
BEST ELECTRIC
East Oak 30” Electric Smoker
The East Oak 30” Electric Smoker is my pick for the best electric smoker because it takes the basic electric smoker idea and adds a few practical upgrades. It is not the smoker I’d choose for the strongest BBQ flavor, but for easy smoking with very little effort, it makes a lot of sense.
Why this works
- Simple plug-in setup
- Larger wood chip tray means less refilling
- Glass door and light make it easier to check food
- Built-in meat probe is useful for beginners
- More modern feature set than many basic electric smokers
Cooking experience
Electric smokers are the easiest smokers to use because there is no fire to manage. You plug it in, set the temperature, add wood chips, and let the heating element do the work. That makes the East Oak a really approachable option if you want to smoke food without learning charcoal, pellets, or offset fire management.
I usually like electric smokers most for fish, chicken, ribs, and smaller pork cuts. They can handle heavier cuts too, but they do not give you the same bark or smoke character as charcoal, pellet, or offset cooking. The East Oak does better than a lot of basic electrics because the chip tray lasts longer, so you are not opening the smoker constantly to add more wood.
The glass door is useful, but you still need to remember that every smoker loses heat when you open it. The bigger advantage is being able to check progress without disturbing the cook as much. I also like that it has a meat probe built in because that helps newer cooks focus on internal temperature instead of guessing.
What to expect
- Very easy to use
- Good for fish, chicken, ribs, pork, and simple smoking
- Less smoke flavor than charcoal, pellet, or offset
- No grilling ability
- Cold weather can affect performance
- Best choice here if you want the simplest smoker possible
Pros
- Very easy to use
- Good for beginners
- Larger wood chip tray
- Built-in meat probe
- Glass door and internal light
- Good choice for fish and chicken
Cons
- No grilling ability
- Less smoke flavor than charcoal or offset
- Not ideal for very cold weather
- Newer brand than Masterbuilt
- Not the best choice for heavy bark on brisket
Who it's best for
If you want a simple plug-in smoker with very little fire management.
Who should skip it
If you want strong smoke flavor, grilled finishes, or traditional BBQ cooking.
Also available at: Amazon
BEST DRUM
Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Drum Smoker
The Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco is my pick for the best drum smoker because it is more versatile than a basic barrel smoker. I am not a huge fan of every barrel-style smoker, but the Bronco is the one I’d happily recommend because the design actually makes sense for backyard use.
Read our full review of the Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco →
Why this works
- Can smoke on the grate or hang meat from hooks
- Charcoal basket is better than many simple drum smokers
- Basket can be raised for grilling
- Holds steady enough once the vents are set
- Gives you a lot of charcoal cooking ability for the price
Cooking experience
The Bronco is not set-and-forget, but it is not difficult either. Once you get the charcoal going and set the vents, it can sit at smoking temperature for a long time with only occasional checking. In good weather, we’ve had no problem getting long low and slow cooks out of a full charcoal basket.
What makes the Bronco better than a lot of barrel smokers is the grilling setup. You can raise the charcoal basket up closer to the cooking grate, which means you are not trying to grill from the bottom of a deep drum. That makes it much more useful as an everyday charcoal cooker, not just a smoker you drag out for ribs.
I also like that it gives you both a standard grate and hooks. Hanging meat in a drum smoker is one of the things this style does really well, and the Bronco gives you that option without making the whole smoker feel too basic. The outside drum quality is not amazing, so I would still look after it properly, but the cooking design is strong.
What to expect
- Average drum quality, so keep it covered and out of the rain
- Built-in thermometer may be off, but mine was consistent
- More hands-on than the Pit Barrel because you can adjust the vents
- Can genuinely grill, not just smoke
- Strong all-round choice if you want one charcoal smoker to do more jobsBest choice here if you want drum smoking with more control and versatility
Pros
- Smokes really well
- Can grill better than many drum smokers
- Includes hooks for hanging meat
- Good charcoal basket setup
- Fairly steady once dialed in
Cons
- Not set-and-forget
- Exterior quality is average
- Needs weather protection
- Less precise than digital smokers
- Grease can collect around the intake area
Who it's best for
If you want one drum smoker that can smoke and grill properly.
Who should skip it
If you want one drum smoker that can smoke and grill properly.
Also available at: Walmart
BEST OFFSET
Oklahoma Joe’s Highland
The Oklahoma Joe’s Highland is my pick for the best offset smoker for learning fire management. It is not a premium offset, and I would not pretend it is, but it gives backyard cooks a realistic way to learn traditional offset smoking without spending thousands.
Why this works
- Real offset smoker layout at a more approachable price
- Lets you cook with charcoal and wood splits
- Main chamber has enough room for family BBQ
- Firebox can be used for reverse searing
- Teaches real fire management instead of hiding the process
Cooking experience
The Highland is a much more hands-on smoker than anything else in this list. You need to build and maintain a clean fire, watch your temperature, manage airflow, and add fuel regularly. If that sounds annoying, this is not the smoker for you. But if you want to learn proper offset cooking, that is exactly why it is useful.
One of the biggest things to understand is that the Highland does not cook evenly from one end to the other. The grate closest to the firebox naturally runs hotter than the far side. In our use, that hot side can be significantly warmer, so you need to place food carefully or move it during the cook. That is not necessarily a deal-breaker. It is just part of learning to cook on an offset.
The Highland is also handy for reverse searing because you can smoke in the main chamber and then finish over the fire in the side box. That is one of my favorite things about the setup. It is basic, but it is functional, and it gives you a proper old-school smoking experience.
What to expect
- Needs regular fire management
- Thin metal compared with premium offsets
- Hotter near the firebox than the chimney end
- Some smoke leakage is normal
- Harder to run in cold or windy weather
- Best choice here if you want to learn traditional offset smoking
Pros
- Real offset smoking experience
- Good size for backyard cooks
- Useful for learning fire management
- Firebox can be used for grilling
- More affordable than serious heavy offsets
- Can make excellent BBQ with practice
Cons
- Needs frequent attention
- Thin metal compared with premium offsets
- Temperature varies across the cooking chamber
- Some smoke leakage
- Takes practice
Who it's best for
If you want to learn old-school offset smoking without spending thousands.
Who should skip it
If you want easy BBQ or steady temperatures without managing a fire.
Also available at: Walmart
Other Smokers I Still Rate
PORTABLE PICK
Z Grills Cruiser 200A
I really like the Z Grills Cruiser 200A, but I’m not making it one of the main winners here because availability looks less stable than the other smokers on this list. If you can still find it at a good price, it is one of the most useful small pellet smokers I’ve cooked on.
Why this works
- Genuinely portable
- Easy to use for small cooks
- Pellet hopper is large enough for low and slow cooking
- Works well when you do not want to fire up a full-size smoker
- One of my favorite small smokers for convenience
Cooking experience
We’ve used the Cruiser for years, and it is one of those smokers that gets used more than you might expect. Because it is small, it heats up without needing to warm a huge cooking chamber, and it is easy to use for a quick chicken, sausages, fish, ribs, or a smaller pork cook.
For smoking, the main thing to watch is that the firepot sits close to the cooking grate. Even with the heat deflector, food can get a bit too much heat from underneath if you leave it sitting the same way for the whole cook. When I’m smoking on it, I’ll often flip meat when it is time to wrap so one side is not taking all the heat.
I probably use the Cruiser for grilling-style cooks as much as smoking. It is not direct flame grilling, so do not expect a steakhouse sear, but it gives you that wood-fired flavor in a small, easy package. If Z Grills still had this properly in their current range, I’d be more comfortable making it a main pick.
What to expect
- Availability may not be stable long term
- Great small smoker if you can still find it
- Limited capacity compared with a full-size pellet smoker
- Food can get too much heat underneath if you do not move or flip it
- Better for small households, patios, camping-style use, and quick cooks
Pros
- Small and easy to move
- Great for quick cooks
- Efficient with pellets
- Useful for smoking and indirect grilling
- Lockable lid
Cons
- Limited cooking space
- Food can get too much heat underneath
- No fancy features
Who it's best for
If you want a small pellet smoker for quick cooks or limited space.
Who should skip it
If you want a full-size smoker or the safest long-term product recommendation.
More Smoker Guides to Help You Choose
If you’re still comparing smoker types, these guides go deeper into each category with more models, trade-offs, and buying advice.
BEST PELLET SMOKERS
Compare more pellet smokers if you want easy wood-fired cooking and want to see how the Z Grills 700D4E stacks up.
BEST CHARCOAL SMOKERS
Compare charcoal smokers if you want stronger fire flavor and are choosing between gravity-fed, kamado, and drum setups.
BEST ELECTRIC SMOKERS
See more electric smokers if you want simple plug-in smoking and want to compare the East Oak with other easy options.
BEST KAMADO SMOKERS
Compare kamado smokers if you want one charcoal cooker for low smoking, hot grilling, and steady heat.
BEST OFFSET SMOKERS
Compare offset smokers if you want traditional fire management and want to see more premium options.
BEST SMALL SMOKERS
Start here if you need something compact for small spaces, patios, camping-style use, or smaller cooks.
How to Choose the Right Smoker Based on How You Actually Cook
The right smoker depends less on what is technically “best” and more on how much effort you want to put into cooking.
Some people love managing fire. Some people want to press a button and get dinner started. Neither is wrong, but buying the wrong type of smoker is one of the easiest ways to end up disappointed.
Do You Want to Manage a Fire, or Not?
If you do not want to manage a fire, choose the Z Grills 700D4E or East Oak electric smoker.
The Z Grills still gives you wood-fired pellet flavor, but it handles fuel feeding and temperature control for you. The East Oak is even simpler because it uses an electric heating element and wood chips.
If you want charcoal flavor without full fire management, choose the Masterbuilt Gravity Series. You still need to light charcoal and clean ash, but the fan and controller do most of the temperature work.
If you want to actively manage a fire, choose the Oklahoma Joe’s Highland. That is the most traditional option here.
Do You Want to Grill as Well, or Just Smoke?
If you want a smoker that can also grill properly, the Kamado Joe Classic II is the strongest option. It can smoke low and slow, but it can also get properly hot for charcoal grilling.
The Masterbuilt Gravity Series can also grill, which makes it a good choice if you want charcoal cooking with more convenience.
The Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco is surprisingly useful for grilling because the charcoal basket can be raised closer to the grate.
If you only care about smoking, the Z Grills 700D4E and East Oak electric are easier, but they are not the best grilling choices.
How Much Effort Do You Actually Want to Put In?
Be honest here, because this matters more than features.
Low effort:
- Z Grills 700D4E
- East Oak 30” Electric
- Masterbuilt Gravity Series once lit
Medium effort:
- Kamado Joe Classic II
- Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco
High effort:
- Oklahoma Joe’s Highland
The Highland can make excellent food, but only if you actually want to manage the fire. If you secretly want convenience, buy a pellet smoker or Gravity Series instead.
How Much Food Are You Realistically Cooking?
If you usually cook for a family or a small group, most of these smokers will work.
For larger cooks, the Z Grills 700D4E, Masterbuilt Gravity Series, and Oklahoma Joe’s Highland give you more usable space.
The Kamado Joe Classic II is more limited unless you use the rack system carefully. It is incredibly versatile, but it is not the easiest choice if you regularly need to cook a lot of meat at once.
The East Oak electric has multiple racks, which is useful for fish, jerky, chicken, ribs, and smaller cuts, but the vertical layout is not always as practical for big briskets.
Do You Want Versatility or Just Great BBQ?
For versatility, I’d look at:
- Kamado Joe Classic II
- Masterbuilt Gravity Series
- Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco
These can smoke and grill in a more meaningful way.
For straight smoking, I’d look at:
- Z Grills 700D4E
- East Oak Electric
- Oklahoma Joe’s Highland
The Highland is not easy, but it is the most traditional smoker here. The Z Grills is the easiest full-size all-rounder. The East Oak is the simplest plug-in option.
Quick Reality Check
- If you want easy BBQ most weekends, buy the Z Grills 700D4E.
- If you want charcoal flavor but not full manual control, buy the Masterbuilt Gravity Series.
- If you want one smoker-grill that feels like a long-term investment, buy the Kamado Joe Classic II.
- If you want the simplest possible smoker, buy the East Oak electric.
- If you want to learn real fire management, buy the Oklahoma Joe’s Highland.
- If you want a fun charcoal drum that can also grill, buy the Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco.
Common Mistakes When Buying a Smoker
- Buying an offset smoker when you actually want set-and-forget cooking.
- Choosing an electric smoker and expecting heavy charcoal-style smoke flavor.
- Buying the biggest smoker possible even though you usually cook small amounts.
- Paying for premium features you will not use.
- Ignoring wind, rain, and storage conditions.
- Assuming pellet smokers are good grills.
- Buying a charcoal smoker without thinking about ash cleanup and lighting.
- Choosing a smoker because it ranks everywhere online, not because it suits how you cook.
- Forgetting that convenience usually means less fire flavor.
- Expecting one smoker to be perfect at everything.
FAQs About the Best Smokers on the Market
What is the best smoker for most people?
For most people, I’d choose the Z Grills 700D4E. It is easy to use, large enough for normal backyard cooking, and does not need the same attention as charcoal, kamado, drum, or offset smokers.
It is not the strongest smoke flavor on this list, but it is the smoker I think most people would actually use regularly.
Is a pellet smoker better than a charcoal smoker?
A pellet smoker is better if you want convenience. A charcoal smoker is better if you care more about charcoal flavor and do not mind extra effort.
The Z Grills 700D4E is easier than the Masterbuilt Gravity Series, Kamado Joe Classic II, and Bronco. But the charcoal smokers give you a deeper fire-cooked flavor.
What smoker is easiest for beginners?
The easiest smoker for beginners is either the Z Grills 700D4E or the East Oak electric smoker.
Choose the Z Grills if you want a more traditional backyard BBQ setup with pellet smoke. Choose the East Oak if you want the simplest plug-in option and do not care about grilling.
What smoker gives the best smoke flavor?
For the strongest traditional smoke flavor, the Oklahoma Joe’s Highland has the highest ceiling because it is a real offset smoker. But it also takes the most effort.
For a better balance of flavor and ease, the Masterbuilt Gravity Series is a strong choice because it gives you charcoal flavor with digital temperature control.
Should I buy an offset smoker as my first smoker?
Only if you actually want to manage a fire.
The Oklahoma Joe’s Highland can teach you a lot, but it is not a lazy smoker. If you want easy results while you learn BBQ basics, start with the Z Grills 700D4E, Masterbuilt Gravity Series, or East Oak electric instead.
Is the Kamado Joe Classic II worth it over a cheaper charcoal smoker?
Yes, if you want one cooker that can smoke, grill, roast, and hold heat extremely well.
The Kamado Joe Classic II costs more than a basic charcoal smoker, but it feels like a more complete outdoor cooker. I’d choose it over the Classic III for most people because it already has the main features you need.
Final Thoughts: Which Smoker Should You Buy?
If I had to choose one smoker for most backyard cooks, I’d choose the Z Grills 700D4E. It is easy to use, practical, and good enough for the kind of BBQ most people actually cook regularly.
If you want charcoal flavor with less work, choose the Masterbuilt Gravity Series.
If you want a smoker that can also grill properly and feels like a long-term investment, choose the Kamado Joe Classic II.
If you want the easiest smoker possible, choose the East Oak 30” Electric Smoker.
If you like charcoal drum cooking, choose the Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco.
And if you want to learn the old-school way, managing a real fire in a side firebox, choose the Oklahoma Joe’s Highland
There is no single best smoker for everyone. But if you choose based on how much effort you want to put in, how much food you cook, and whether you care more about convenience or fire flavor, you will end up with a smoker you actually enjoy using.
Kate Brown is the founder of Burning Brisket, where she shares hands-on smoker reviews, barbecue gear guides, and practical tips for backyard BBQ. She has cooked extensively on charcoal, pellet, electric, and kamado smokers, using real-world experience to help beginners choose the right equipment and make better barbecue at home. Her focus is honest, straightforward advice that makes smoking and grilling easier without unnecessary complexity.
